Over the past 14 months, Rodri has remained predominantly unavailable due to an anterior cruciate ligament injury incurred against Arsenal, managing a mere 588 minutes on the pitch with Manchester City owing to multiple relapses, the most recent of which kept him out from the midweek 4-1 triumph over Borussia Dortmund in the Champions League. Although Pep Guardiola has stated that “he is not expected to be sidelined long,” the 29-year-old is fundamental to the coach’s system. Below, we evaluate the alternatives …
Nico Gonzalez
“The go-to alternative when Rodri is unavailable is absolutely Nico. Nico is showing steps forward,” the City manager remarked before Sunday’s 3-1 success versus Bournemouth. At a height of 6ft 2in and just 23 at the time he was signed for a significant fee from Porto in the recent transfer window, González is a near mirror image of Rodri. Indeed, Guardiola referred to the former Barcelona player as a “young Rodri” in the past, but against Bournemouth there were moments when he was caught and turned over in midfield as Rodri, in top form, would not be. It is little disgrace, though, in not being in the same league as the Ballon d’Or winner.
Mateo Kovacic
The ongoing unavailability of City’s only other holding midfielder to an ankle problem will be a challenge for City should Nico also pick up an injury during Rodri’s absence. The midfielder has shone regularly for City since arriving at the club from Chelsea for £25m in June 2023 and has a CV that makes clear he is a stellar talent. His past employers feature Dinamo Zagreb, Inter and Real Madrid. He also has a glut of accolades to his name, such as one La Liga title, one Premier League title and four Champions League trophies.
Rico Lewis
The young defender has accumulated 103 outings for City, roughly a 25% of which have come as a defensive midfielder. The boy from Bury is proficient in the all-around awareness, technique, challenges and energy the position requires in a Guardiola-led side, yet the manager has cited Lewis’s relatively short stature as a disadvantage in that role. “It’s important to have physicality, for clear reasons,” he said. “It was lower [needed] in Barcelona, Bayern Munich [Guardiola’s previous clubs].” Turning 21 later this month, Lewis is still developing and has room for development.
The Versatile Defender
“What he brings to the pitch is exceptional quality as a centre-back and possibly as a crucial No 6.” The perspective expressed by Thomas Tuchel and one that echoes Guardiola in regards to the ‘English defender’. Out of Stones’s 408 club games, 27 have been as a holding midfielder and he excelled in that role when stepping up from the back line to play alongside Rodri in City’s 2023 Champions League final victory over Inter. “The all-round vision was the hardest for me,” Stones noted about playing in the position. “I haven’t got that – I believe I’ve developed, but that comes from understanding where to take possession and how to receive it in specific scenarios.”
Tijjani Reijnders
The Dutchman was signed by City from Milan in the summer as a stand-in for Kevin De Bruyne. As he put it himself at the summer’s Club World Cup: “The No 8 position is why they [City] signed me. My task is to occupy that role and give my all to prove that I merit a place.” With González dealing with a fitness issue, the Dutch international lined up as a defensive midfielder in the recent 1-0 setback at Aston Villa and was shifted forward when the Spanish player came on just after the second half, the moment giving a indication of where he ranks in Guardiola’s plans, specifically as a deputy.
Matheus Nunes
Of Brazilian origin Portugal international has featured in just nine occasions as a deep-lying midfielder during his career with the single appearance in the position for City coming against Nottingham Forest in September 2023. He played the full 90 and contributed an goal-setting pass in a 2-0 win.
Kalvin Phillips
The club’s squad member is just 29. Additionally, he has operated as a deep midfielder on 164 occasions in his career and performed adequately in the role to be called up by England. Yet, it is evident he is not trusted of Guardiola.